Why did Chris Vrenna leave Nine Inch Nails?

Written by Jeff Campbell in Band Members,Goth/Industrial Last Updated November 17, 2022

Chris Vrenna leave NIN lg

Chris Vrenna is best known as the former live drummer for Nine Inch Nails. He was a big part of the band from the beginning until 1997. Vrenna’s sudden exit left his fans to wonder: Why did Chris Vrenna leave Nine Inch Nails?

Here is what I know:

Chris Vrenna left Nine Inch Nails twice, with the first time being in 1990 after a fallout with band leader Trent Reznor over the artistic direction for the band. But Vrenna re-joined in 1992 for Broken and The Downward Spiral. But he quit again in 1997 after another disagreement with Reznor.

But he was on stage with Reznor when Nine Inch Nails was inducted into the Rock n’ Roll Hall of Fame in 2020.

After quitting Nine Inch Nails, Vrenna formed his band Tweaker with Clint Walsh and released three full-length studio albums: The Attraction to All Things Uncertain (2001), 2 A.M. Wakeup Call (2004), and Call The Time Eternity (2012).

The band is active but hasn’t released any new albums in years.

So, did Chris’s career end after leaving NIN? Did he ever regret quitting the band? And what has Chris Vrenna been up to these days?

Let us find out:

Does Chris Vrenna play on Pretty Hate Machine?

Chris Vrenna does not play any instruments on Pretty Hate Machine despite being the group’s drummer at the time. He is, however, credited with “continuity, digital editing” on the credits. Most of the record was done with a drum machine rather than live drums.

Pretty Hate Machine, NIN’s debut album, was released on October 20, 1989, by TVT Records in the United States. It was a moderate success.

During that tour, Chris initially handled the band’s electronics but was later deemed unfit by Trent. Gary Talpas on keyboards replaced Vrenna, with Vrenna moving to drums.

Therefore, the album’s tour series mainly consisted of Trent on vocals and guitars, Chris Vrenna on drums, Richard Patrick on back-up vocals and guitars, and Gary Talpas on synths.

I was lucky enough to see Nine Inch Nails on that tour (opening for the Jesus and Mary Chain). To say they were fantastic would be a complete understatement.

According to Chris, Pretty Hate Machine “introduced people to non-organic sounds” they would have never heard. It was dark but honest too.

Over the years, the album garnered plenty of listeners and peaked at No.75 on Billboard’s 200 Album Chart. It also went on to become a certified triple platinum album.

How long was Chris Vrenna in Nine Inch Nails?

Chris Vrenna stayed with the legendary industrial rock band Nine Inch Nails from 1989 to 1997 with a 2-year absence from 1990-1992. During these years, Chris worked on three studio albums of NIN.

The albums garnered success, and the band got bigger.

And as usually happens when bands are evolving, Reznor’s aspiration to introduce new material into the band’s discography did not match with the ideas of other band members, especially Chris’.

The indifference led to verbal insults where Reznor allegedly called Vrenna a “musical janitor”. Reznor finally fired Vrenna in 1990, but the two reconciled in 1992.

The two put the dust on their old hiatus and worked on making their two subsequent projects, Broken (1992) and The Downward Spiral (1993-1997), a success.

In both these albums, Vrenna handled drums on a few songs and also did a lot of the drum and synth programming. 

Both of those albums went on to become record-breaking albums that solidified Nine Inch Nails as THE top industrial band.

But the pressures of being in a band that was really just a 1-man show with a bunch of hired guns was too much, and Vrenna decided to quit NIN again in 1997. This time for good.

Was Chris Vrenna inducted into the Hall of Fame?

Chris Vrenna was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2020 alongside Trent Reznor and a select group of current and former members of Nine Inch Nails. Vrenna also gave a heartfelt speech at the occasion. 

The other members aside from Vrenna and Reznor that were part of the ceremony included:

  • Atticus Ross (currently the only other official member of the band aside from Reznor)
  • Robin Finck (long-time guitarist and current touring member of the band)
  • Danny Lohner (long-time former member from 1993-2003 who contributed to The Downward Spiral and The Fragile in addition to some remix and live releases.)
  • Ilan Rubin (Current touring drummer who also plays a variety of other instruments. He’s been in the live band since 2009.)
  • Alessandro Cortini (Current touring member who initially played keyboards but transitioned more to bass and guitar after Atticus Ross joined).

So as you see, only Vrenna and Danny Lohner were invited from the long list of former Nine Inch Nails members (a list that is at least 22 people long).

Vrenna took a moment to thank everybody for the support and remembered the journey that began three decades ago.

Here is what Chris said:

“My years with Trent and NIN are some of the best of my life, and I continue to treasure those memories. And now, those memories can live in the Rock and Roll HOF. Thank you to every single fan… that continues to discover NIN. I am eternally grateful for everything we accomplished with NIN.” 

Nine Inch Nails is known as the band for bringing a new wave of the dark era in the 1980s and shaping industrial music in Cleveland.

For the most part, Vrenna and Reznor can be called the light-bearers helping the band taste the success.

Is Chris Vrenna friends with Trent Reznor?

Chris Vrenna and Trent Reznor are friends and stay in touch with each other. They have resolved their past arguments and moved on in life.

Trent and Chris are high school buddies who played together for a band in Cleveland and became friends after Vrenna bought his drum machine to play in NIN.

The pair had a lot in common and hit off almost instantly. They ended up working on several projects together in Nine Inch Nails and even tasted great success.

Unfortunately, the duo had a slight fallout in 1990.

Based on many assumptions by fans, the fallout was probably because Chris did not get paid as much as Trent as the band started getting bigger.

Many fans were quick to notice the unspoken feud. But the duo has constantly maintained that they have walked past the debate and mended their ways long back.

As of now, Reznor and Vrenna are on speaking terms and are good friends.

Did Chris Vrenna help start Nine Inch Nails?

Chris Vrenna did help start Nine Inch Nails. While he did not really play on Pretty Hate Machine, he did participate in the recording and contributed extensively to the tours that followed. Vrenna also worked on NIN’s following two albums. 

American alternative rock act Nine Inch Nails was born in Cleveland in 1988.

While Reznor wrote, arranged, performed, and produced most of the material, Vrenna silently lent his significant contribution to several projects. He took care of the complex production process used in creating the band’s debut album “Pretty Hate Machine” (1989) and other projects.

Trent and Vrenna’s journey was similar in many ways, as both of them worked with several bands before creating their own material.

But they differed in one aspect.

While Trent had the chance to work with reputed artists from the start- also working as a roadie for a legendary band such as Ministry, Chris’s journey was slow.

Want to know how long Trent Reznor worked as a roadie for Ministry? Read my recent article. And is that really Trent singing on the Ministry side-project 1000 Homo DJs?

Just click that link to read it on my site.

Nine Inch Nails: Chris Vrenna Part 1

Conclusion

The Grammy-award winner Chris Vrenna worked with the industrial rock band Nine Inch Nails from 1989 to 1997. He mostly worked on keyboard and drums for three albums in NIN.

However, after working for a brief period, Vrenna decided to quit the band just when it started to reach the top charts. But many fans have wondered for years, trying to understand the reason before he suddenly quit.

Although there is no confirmed statement made by Trent or Chris, fans assumed that money could have been an apparent reason behind the hiatus, compelling Vrenna to leave in 1997.

Vrenna went ahead to create another band called Tweaker and subsequently released three full-length albums. After this, the band has not released any more albums.

As of now, Vrenna has been teaching music at Calhoun Community for five years, and the chances that the group will reconnect are pretty slim.

Photos that requires attribution:

Chris_Vrenna_drums by Nick Y and Trent Reznor, February, 2008 (Press Photo) by Nine Inch Nails are licensed under CC2.0 and was cropped, edited, and had a text overlay added and the images were merged.

Top Related Posts